Click Here!Click Here!
Home / Health / If adhered to, branded diets are ‘similarly effective’
If adhered to, branded diets are ‘similarly effective’

If adhered to, branded diets are ‘similarly effective’

According to a new meta-analysis conducted by researchers during McMaster University in Hamilton, Canada, and published in JAMA, branded diets – such as Atkins or Weight Watchers – tend to have identical levels of efficacy if they are adhered to.

obese male measuring waist
The investigate showed that a impact opposite aspects of dieting had on weight detriment depended on a theatre of a diet.

“We wanted to be a initial to compare, in an evidence-based fashion, all existent randomized trials of branded diets to establish their efficacy with courtesy to weight loss,” says lead author Bradley Johnston, partner highbrow of clinical epidemiology of a Michael G. DeGroote School of Medicine during McMaster University.

Johnston’s group achieved a meta-analysis of 48 randomized clinical trials that investigated weight detriment during 6 and 12 months regulating branded diets. Overall, a studies demeanour during some-more than 7,200 overweight and portly people, who had a median age of 46.

The diets examined opposite a studies were Atkins, Weight Watchers, Zone, Jenny Craig, LEARN, Nutrisystem, Ornish, Volumetrics, Rosemary Conley, Slimming World and South Beach.

The researchers found that during 6 months, investigate participants on low-carbohydrate diets mislaid 19 lb some-more than control participants who were not on any diet. Participants on low-fat diets, meanwhile, mislaid 17 lb some-more than those on no diet.


After 12 months, however, a meta-analysis found that there was no disproportion between a low-carbohydrate and low-fat diets in terms of weight lost.

Also, a investigate showed that a impact opposite aspects of dieting had on weight detriment depended on a theatre of a diet. For instance, during 6 months, behavioral support was shown to raise weight detriment by about 7 lb. At 12 months, however, a impact of practice was poignant – improving weight detriment by about 4.5 lb.

Differences in diets’ impact on weight detriment ‘relatively small’

Researcher Geoff Ball, associate highbrow and plumpness consultant in a Faculty of Medicine Dentistry during a University of Alberta, says of a results:

“Given a recognition of these diets around a world, there has been a genuine miss of investigate to inspect their relations benefits. But overall, a differences between a opposite diets per their impact on weight detriment were comparatively small.”

The authors stress that a commentary are sold to people who stranded to a branded diets over a brief term. Further investigate is indispensable to inspect a long-term effects of these diets and to consider what other outcomes might be associated to them.

In January, Medical News Today reported on a investigate questioning high-protein diets, such as a Dukan diet. The researchers found that when rats were placed on an homogeneous diet, they showed symptoms of poignant kidney damage.

In May, a new low-carbohydrate vegan diet – dubbed a “Eco-Atkins” – was found to be effective not usually in losing weight, though also during shortening a risk of heart disease. A investigate published in BMJ Open celebrated that participants who followed a diet had 10% reduce cholesterol and had mislaid an normal of 4 lb extra, compared with participants who followed a high-carbohydrate, low-fat diet.

The Weight Watchers diet, meanwhile, has formerly been found – by a investigate published in The Lancet – to be about twice as effective for losing weight as customary weight detriment care.

In that study, people following a Weight Watchers diet stayed on a diet in incomparable numbers, mislaid some-more fat mass and weight and had larger reductions in waist measurements than participants on a customary caring program.

Written by David McNamee



View all articles created by David, or follow him on:



About admin

Scroll To Top