Down dual games to one and confronting rejecting in their Division Series conflicting a Nationals, a Dodgers had a formidable choice to make per their starting pitcher for Tuesday’s Game 4 in Los Angeles—so formidable that a classification motionless to nap on it, so to speak. Not until 5 hours before diversion time did Los Angeles announce that ace Clayton Kershaw would take a round on 3 days of rest.
Normally, this would be an easy decision, though Kershaw missed 2 1/2 months, from late Jun to early September, with a herniated front in his back. While he had worked his approach behind into a slit over a march of his 5 regular-season starts in Sep and October—allowing 6 runs (four earned) in 28 innings and posting a 27/2 strikeout-to-walk ratio—he maxed out during 91 pitches in those games and worked by a final of them, his Oct. 1 spin conflicting a Giants.
In NLDS Game 1 final Friday in Washington, a Nationals forced Kershaw to work even harder. Only in a initial inning did he retire a Nats in order, and even then, he indispensable 17 pitches to strike out a side interjection to Bryce Harper’s eight-pitch image appearance. The Nationals installed a bases in a 23-pitch second inning, and 3 hits and a travel constructed dual runs during a 26-pitch third inning. Kershaw indispensable 16 pitches to get by a fourth, when he gave adult another run, and he left dual runners on after an 18-pitch fifth inning. His 101 pitches were a many he had thrown given his Jun 26 tour conflicting a Pirates, a final one before he went on a infirm list, and many of those 101 pitches were in high-stress situations.
Manager Dave Roberts’s bewilderment was difficult even serve by final Saturday’s rainout, that meant that Game 2 starter Rich Hill would need to come behind on 3 days’ rest to start Game 5. Hill has never started on brief rest and hasn’t left past 93 pitches given Jul 7, when he was still with a Athletics; scald problems singular him to 6 turns and an normal of 85 pitches after being acquired by Los Angeles on Aug. 1. What’s more, he scuffled by 82 pitches in Game 2 of a array as a Nationals got overly familiar with his curveball.
With a hostility to move Hill behind on brief rest, a Dodgers’ preference boiled down to this: Bring behind Kershaw on 3 days’ rest and afterwards use some multiple of 20-year-old rookie Julio Urias, Hill and all other accessible hands in Washington for Game 5; or use Urias and a bullpen for Game 4 and hope that Kershaw would get a possibility to representation on normal rest in Game 5. Urias pitched to a 3.39 ERA and 3.17 FIP with 9.8 strikeouts per 9 in 77 large joining innings this year, and he has demonstrated intrepidity over his years, though his 132 sum innings are already 51 2/3 past final year’s total, and he final pitched on Sept. 30, creation sharpness a regard either or not he’s thrown into a glow in Game 4 or 5.
(For what it’s worth, Nationals manager Dusty Baker also didn’t name his Game 4 starter until Tuesday morning, though carrying already announced that ace Max Scherzer wouldn’t representation until Game 5, a choice of a less-than-mint Joe Ross over rookie Reynaldo Lopez was a footnote by comparison.)
Neither of Roberts’s choices was optimal, though a good news for a Dodgers is that Kershaw’s story on brief rest is mostly positive; he’s finished it in Game 4 of a Division Series in any of a past 3 seasons. In a 2013 NLDS conflicting a Braves, with a Dodgers adult dual games to one, he went 6 innings and authorised only 3 hits and dual unmerited runs, whiffing 6 over a march of 91 pitches; a Dodgers sealed out a array in that one interjection to Juan Uribe’s eight-inning homer off David Carpenter. In 2014, confronting a Cardinals with L.A. down dual games to one, Kershaw tossed 6 innings of one-hit shutout round on 94 pitches though gave adult dual singles and an doubtful three-run homer by lefty Matt Adams to start a seventh; manager Don Mattingly didn’t have a pitcher in his bullpen that he devoted some-more than his flagging ace, who unraveled over a march of his final 8 pitches. Last year, conflicting a Mets and again down dual games to one, Kershaw threw 7 innings of three-hit, one-run ball, regulating 94 pitches; a Dodgers won to send a array behind to L.A., where they mislaid Game 5.
Kershaw’s sum line in those 3 starts: 19 innings, 10 hits, 6 runs (four earned) and a 23/4 strikeout-to-walk ratio for a 1.89 ERA. In this day and age, we can’t ask for most some-more than that given how low he works into counts. This time around, a Dodgers have a improved bullpen to behind him up, despite one that worked 6 innings on Monday in service of Kenta Maeda, with Pedro Baez and Joe Blanton both going past 30 pitches and Kenley Jansen removing illuminated adult for 4 ninth-inning runs to blow a diversion open before removing a offshoot after only 16 pitches.
As Hall of Fame manager Leo Durocher famously said, “You don’t save a pitcher for tomorrow. Tomorrow it competence rain.” The situations aren’t utterly parallel, though during a AL wild-card game, a Orioles mislaid since of Buck Showalter’s hostility to use lights-out closer Zach Britton in a tie diversion on a road, since a manager was watchful for a better, some-more text event that competence never come—and didn’t. The Braves mislaid a aforementioned 2013 Division Series diversion in partial since it was Carpenter and not star closer Craig Kimbrel confronting Uribe; manager Fredi Gonzalez didn’t wish to go to his closer in a eighth because, well, you’ll have to ask him.
The point—underscored in a certain instruction by Kershaw’s possess history, and by other examples of assertive staff government such as Terry Francona’s bullpen use in this year’s Division Series conflicting a Red Sox—is that it’s improved to go with your best pitchers, even underneath suboptimal conditions, since during slightest we took your best shot. That’s what a Dodgers are doing. If they win, they can worry about patching together 9 innings conflicting Scherzer. If they lose, during slightest they won’t have to consternation what competence have been had they given a planet’s best pitcher one final chance.