HTTP/1.1 302 Found Date: Tue, 30 Sep 2014 04:39:53 GMT Server: Apache Set-Cookie: NYT-S=deleted; expires=Thu, 01-Jan-1970 00:00:01 GMT; path=/; domain=www.stg.nytimes.com Set-Cookie: NYT-S=0MHqiDQYQOJGrDXrmvxADeHEuaCWBFNjKkdeFz9JchiAIUFL2BEX5FWcV.Ynx4rkFI; expires=Thu, 30-Oct-2014 04:39:53 GMT; path=/; domain=.nytimes.com Location: http://www.nytimes.com/2014/09/29/us/costs-can-go-up-fast-when-er-is-in-network-but-the-doctors-are-not.html?_r=0 Content-Length: 0 Cneonction: close Content-Type: text/html; charset=UTF-8 HTTP/1.1 200 OK Server: Apache Cache-Control: no-cache Channels: NytNow Content-Type: text/html; charset=utf-8 Transfer-Encoding: chunked Date: Tue, 30 Sep 2014 04:39:53 GMT X-Varnish: 1109787601 Age: 0 Via: 1.1 varnish X-Cache: MISS X-API-Version: 5-5 X-PageType: article Connection: close 00278e
- Charles M. Blow
- David Brooks
- Frank Bruni
- Roger Cohen
- Gail Collins
- Ross Douthat
- Maureen Dowd
- Thomas L. Friedman
- Nicholas Kristof
- Paul Krugman
- Joe Nocera
Credit Ozier Muhammad/The New York Times
When Jennifer Hopper raced to the emergency room after her husband, Craig, took a baseball in the face, she made sure they went to a hospital in their insurance network in Texas. So when they got a $ 937 bill from the emergency room doctor, she called the insurer, assuming it was in error.
But the bill was correct: UnitedHealthcare, the insurance company, had paid its customary fee of $ 151.02 and expected the Hoppers to pay the remaining $ 785.98, because the doctor at Seton Northwest Hospital in Austin did not participate in their network.
âIt never occurred to me that the first line of defense, the person you have to see in an in-network emergency room, could be out of the network,â said Ms. Hopper, who has spent months fighting the bill. âIn-network means we just get the building? I thought the doctor came with the E.R.â
Patients have no choice about which physician they see when they go to an emergency room, even if they have the presence of mind to visit a hospital that is in their insurance network. In the piles of forms that patients sign in those chaotic first moments is often an acknowledgment that they understand some providers may be out of network.
Credit Ozier Muhammad/The New York Times
But even the most basic visits with emergency room physicians and other doctors called in to consult are increasingly leaving patients with hefty bills: More and more, doctors who work in emergency rooms are private contractors who are out of network or do not accept any insurance plans.
When legislators in Texas demanded some data from insurers last year, they learned that up to half of the hospitals that participated with UnitedHealthcare, Humana and Blue Cross-Blue Shield â Texasâs three biggest insurers â had no in-network emergency room doctors. Out-of-network payments to emergency room physicians accounted for 40 to 70 percent of the money spent on emergency care at in-network hospitals, researchers with the Center for Public Policy Priorities in Austin found.
âItâs very common and thereâs little consumers can do to prevent it and protect themselves â itâs a roll of the dice,â said Stacey Pogue, a senior policy analyst with the nonpartisan center and an author of the study.
While patients have complained of surprise out-of-network charges in hospitals from some other specialists â particularly anesthesiologists, radiologists and pathologists â the situation with emergency room doctors is even more troubling, patient advocates say. For one thing, patients cannot be expected to review provider networks in a crisis, and the information to do so is usually not readily available anyway. Moreover, the Texas study found that out-of-network fees paid to emergency room physicians eclipsed the amount of money paid to those other specialists.
When emergency medicine emerged as a specialty in the 1980s, almost all E.R. doctors were hospital employees who typically did not bill separately for their services. Today, 65 percent of hospitals contract out that function. And some emergency medicine staffing groups â many serve a large number of hospitals, either nationally or locally â opt out of all insurance plans.
As more insurance plans contract with narrower networks of doctors to form offerings tailored to the Affordable Care Act, insurers have acquired greater leverage in cutting payments to physicians. While an insurer would have little power to drive a hard bargain with a major hospital that the company needs in its network, it can often pick and choose among physicians, excluding some or offering rates so low that many doctors say their practices are unsustainable.
Dr. Jeffrey Bettinger, chairman of the reimbursement committee of the American College of Emergency Physicians, said that out-of-network emergency room doctors were an unusual phenomenon and expressed doubt that the practice was widespread. When it occurred, he added, it was typically because of insurersâ unwillingness to pay doctors a reasonable rate compared to what they pay hospitals for their services.
The average salary of an emergency room physician was $ 311,000 in 2014, rising from $ 247,000 since 2010 â a period when many other types of doctors experienced declines in salaries, according to Merritt Hawkins, a physician staffing firm.
Hospital charges for emergency care vary widely. A recent study found that hospital charges for a visit involving a serious medical issue in California varied between $ 275 and $ 6,662, just for the facility fee. âMuch of the variation we observe may in fact be entirely random,â wrote the authors, emergency physicians at the University of California San Francisco Medical Center. But that variation often does not directly affect patients, since most hospitals participate in the big insurance plans in their area, and patients tend to know which are in their network, so the insurer covers most of the bill.
But it is a different matter with emergency room doctors who bill out-of-network fees, experts say.
A series of articles by the New York Times correspondent Elisabeth Rosenthal examines the price of medical care in the United States. In each installment, readers were invited to share their perspectives on managing costs and treatment.
When Dr. Michael Schwartzâs daughter went to an emergency room in the Philadelphia suburbs for a reaction to a medication in 2010, she went to an in-network hospital, Bryn Mawr. She was there for a few hours on a cardiac monitor. While most of her care was covered by his familyâs insurer, Capital Blue Cross, a bill of more than $ 2,000 from the out-of-network E.R. physicians for cardiac monitoring was not.
âI tried to negotiate with the physician group, but they wouldnât budge,â said Dr. Schwartz, a pediatrician, who ended up paying $ 1,200, the amount his plan required for his share of out-of-network care. âIt was ridiculous. Iâm a physician and I understand how this works. There was no sign saying, âOur physicians are out-of-network.âÂ â
Likewise, when Luke Adami, 6, sustained a gash to his chin on a playground, his parents rushed him to an emergency room at an in-network facility, Valley Hospital in New Jersey. The parents, Greg and Madeleine Adami, asked about a plastic surgeon to sew him up. Mr. Adami recalled: âYou go to a hospital thatâs in network, your kidâs bleeding. What are you going to say?â
The nurse did not mention that the surgeon she called was out of network and would charge a separate fee. Neither did the plastic surgeon say anything about costs when he came in.
He billed the Adamis $ 4,878 for eight stitches that were coded as âopen wound, jaw, complicated.â âWhen I looked at the bill, I laughed and I told the surgeonâs office, âProcess this claim with my insurer. Iâm not paying out of pocket,âÂ â Mr. Adami said. âThe hospital has control over who they bring in. But I do not.â
Emergency physicians say they are not to blame. âIn general, E.R. physicians try to align themselves with whatever networks their hospitals are in, but sometimes the rates pale compared to what is offered to the hospitals,â said Dr. Bettinger of the emergency physiciansâ group. That often leads to protracted negotiations, he said, but eventually the insurers and the doctors come to agreement and sign a contract.
In the meantime, patients are stuck with out-of-pocket charges. Regulations created by the Affordable Care Act specify that insurers must use the best-paying among three methods for reimbursing out-of-network physicians dispensing emergency care: pay the Medicare rate; pay the median in-network amount for the service; or apply the usual formula they use to determine out-of-network reimbursement, which often depends on âusual and customary ratesâ in the area.
But in most states, doctors can then bill patients for the difference between their charge and what the insurer paid.
In months of dickering over her husbandâs bill, Ms. Hopper has learned much about health insurance in Texas. Watching her travails, her husband, a lawyer, told her: âIf you were my client, Iâd advise you just to pay the $ 800 and move on with your life.â
She was too angry to take his advice.
But if she or her husband ends up in an emergency room again, she knows they will be vulnerable because only a handful of doctors in any of Austinâs emergency rooms participate in insurance plans. She sighed: âEven knowing everything I know now, itâs completely out of your control.â
More on nytimes.com
- © 2014 The New York Times Company
- Contact Us
- Work With Us
- Your Ad Choices
- Terms of Service
- Terms of Sale