Crude Oil Train
A Hondo Railway workman rides on a tanker automobile as rail cars are changed to be unloaded. (Bob Owen/San Antonio Express-News)
Posted: Monday, Sep 1, 2014 8:38 pm
As some-more oil travels along rail, reserve concerns come up
Six days a week, bumping by a scrub, oil trucks lift adult to a rail stations during Muleshoe or Kermit, Dimmit or Roy, Whiteface, Seagraves or Wellman, any of a flyspeck boomtowns of a Permian Basin. By a tracks, roustabouts and railroaders accommodate for a send as aged as their industries. Pumping wanton into tank cars, they step behind as a locomotives surge off toward a send stations of BNSF and Union Pacific, a dual large lines that crisscross a state on their approach to Houston, where 800 miles of lane breeze by a city toward a petroleum barges and refineries of a Gulf Coast.
“First mile in a smoothness process,” says Bruce Carswell, operations manager of a West Texas Lubbock Railway. His write manner, ever polite, turns kindly defensive when he adds: “Railroads have been doing this arrange of commodity and other dangerous line for many, many years. The vast, vast, immeasurable infancy of these shipments never have a problem.”
Across a country, heated inspection has descended on rail movement of crude, a partnership that built a inhabitant appetite complement in a age of John D. Rockefeller and Standard Oil. As trade has surged, a array of accidents, including a fantastic derailment that killed dozens of people final summer in Canada, has led to cheer from glow marshals and assurances from rail attention officials. Federal officials have released a reserve warning and puncture orders. Tensions have escalated rapidly, with protestors restraint a marks outward a refinery final month in a Pacific Northwest.
But in Texas, home of a country’s many inclusive production, biggest valid oil pot and many expanded enlightening capacity, wanton oil rides a rails with tiny oversight. To perform a smallest mandate of a sovereign puncture order, state open reserve officials have concluded to accept some information about potentially flighty wanton nearing from a subterranean arrangement in North Dakota. They do not, however, consider a load imagining in Texas, flitting by from other places or relocating toward a good tellurian heart of Houston. They do not exam a flammability. They do not, in any poignant detail, lane a quantities, movements or destinations.
Now, as sovereign officials start contrast some wells in South Texas for a same bomb properties found in northern samples, some experts contend a state competence be holding a critical reserve risk by branch a blind eye to a wanton churning by a fast expanding rail networks.
“Nobody unequivocally keeps lane of it,” pronounced Sandy Fielden, an attention researcher in Austin for a consulting organisation RBN Energy. “As distant as a reserve of it, a jury is still out.”
For generations of drillers in Texas, where a immeasurable tube complement has grown with a fits and starts of a oil industry’s scandalous business cycle, railroads supposing tiny some-more than a comparatively dear final resort. But in a new bang compared with hydraulic fracturing, producers have increasingly enlisted trains to hoop a unusual glut.
Nationally, according to a Association of American Railroads, carloads of wanton oil grew from 9,500 in 2008 to some-more than 400,000 final year. In a initial entertain of this year, a many new sum accessible from a association, wanton shipments grew to 110,000 compared to 97,000 in a initial entertain of 2013.
By a many new information accessible from a Texas Railroad Commission, that regulates a oil and gas industries (but not, to a befuddlement of many a high propagandize civics class, a railroads), sum rail and boat shipments of oil and oil-like substances rose from about 360,000 barrels in 2011 to about 401,000 barrels in 2012. The elect could customarily guess how many of that trade represented rail shipments, putting a figure during 90 percent.
“Data on rail transportation,” pronounced Ramona Nye, a mouthpiece for a state commission, “is limited.”
The risk announced itself in Jul 2013, when a exile sight carrying 72 tank cars crushed into a tiny traveller city of Le Mégantic, Quebec, casting adult fireballs, environment dozens of building fervent and murdering 47 people. The oil on house — 30,000 gallons per automobile — had come from a Bakken arrangement in a Williston Basin of North Dakota. A month later, U.S. officials from a Pipeline and Hazardous Materials Safety Administration started creation unannounced inspections of producers in a region. They called their debate Operation Classification, nicknamed “The Bakken Blitz.”
In May, formed on a early formula of a operation, a U.S. Department of Transportation released a reserve warning. Citing a volume of wanton oil entrance out of a Bakken, officials urged a railroads to take additional precautions, regulating tank cars with a “highest spin of firmness pretty accessible within their fleet.”
Longstanding sovereign regulations need trains carrying dangerous materials to be remarkable with a diamond-shaped poster for a advantage of puncture responders. Along with a new reserve warning, a dialect released an puncture sequence requiring railroads to take a additional step of notifying state reserve officials opposite a nation of any incoming sight carrying some-more than a million barrels of wanton from a Bakken.
Oil and gas attention officials responded quickly, contesting any need for a notifications. In a news released a week after a sovereign reserve warning, a American Fuel Petrochemical Manufacturers, a trade organisation representing manufacturers of products including gasoline and home heating oil, argued that “Bakken wanton is allied to other light crudes and does not poise risks that are significantly opposite than other crudes or incendiary liquids certified for rail transport.”
In Texas, a avocation of receiving a notifications fell to a multiplication of a state Department of Public Safety. “We’re only a repository they have to news to if they accommodate that threshold, that is intensely high,” pronounced Tom Vinger, a orator for a department. One of a state’s dual categorical rail operators, Union Pacific, “gave us information that said, ‘We don’t have anything that meets a sovereign threshold, have a good day.’”
The other large rail line, BNSF, did yield notice of shipments from a Bakken, according to Vinger. State officials in spin told a suitable counties, he said, nonetheless he declined to mention a series of shipments, a counties endangered or either a notice desirous any sold reserve precautions. Presented with a ask for that information underneath a state open annals law, a department’s lawyers sought an opinion from a profession general. They argued that a annals competence be exempted from open avowal given a tyrannise had remarkable them “confidential.” The profession ubiquitous has not nonetheless released a decision.
In Houston, Bob Royall, partner arch for puncture operations during a Harris County Fire Marshal’s Office, pronounced he did accept an email presentation from state travel authorities. It was informative, in a singular way. It disclosed that an normal of dual trains a month enter a county carrying Bakken wanton in additional of a million-gallon sovereign threshold. That amount, he noted, would fill about 35 tank cars. “There is no automobile for us to establish if there is a sight with reduction than a threshhold entrance through,” Royall said. Asked to news any reserve concerns per a sight too tiny to accommodate a threshold, he added, “A 25- or 30-car derailment is going to be a inauspicious eventuality that will taxation a resources of any department.”
Spokesmen for BNSF and Union Pacific declined solid talk requests, referring instead to a industry’s created statements on a topic.
But some officials have begun to think a problem too pervasive to pin only on prolongation volume in North Dakota. Derailments, spills and fires involving wanton from several opposite regions have caused repairs in Minnesota, Mississippi, Alabama and Lynchburg, Virginia, where thousands of gallons of wanton sinister a James River.
In June, Sens. Ronald Wyden and Jeffrey Merkley, Democrats of Oregon, where rail cars broach wanton to terminals in Portland, publicly questioned a concentration on oil prolongation volumes in North Dakota. Is it possible, they asked in a minute to a National Transportation Safety Board, that “crude oil constructed outward of a Bakken and ecstatic on railroads poses intensity hazards in a box of an accident?”
There was a time when years would go by between oil spills from rail cars in Texas. This is a fact: In a 1990s, a Dallas Cowboys won a Super Bowl some-more mostly than sovereign officials counted a wanton brief from a sight in their state. Since a escalation of a hydraulic fracturing materialisation in 2010, though, a sovereign Pipeline and Hazardous Materials Safety Administration has counted 68 such spills, compared to a sum of 9 in a whole prior 40 years.
So far, there have been 8 spills this year alone. They have been small. No one has been injured.
But their numbers have neatly increasing even as other aspects of rail reserve have improved. Over a past decade, according to statistics from a Federal Railroad Administration, accidents and derailments showed a solid decrease in Texas, reflecting a national trend.
As a oil bang accelerates, with Texas prolongation reaching 3 million barrels a day this year for a initial time given a 1970s, rail companies are expanding to lift some-more wanton by a state. US Development Group has fabricated a network of specialized facilities, including terminals in Bayport and San Antonio. Rangeland Energy, formed in Sugar Land, is building a rail depot nearby Loving, New Mexico, set to open in Oct with high speed trains eventually shipping 100,000 barrels a day. Facilities including Southton Rail Yard and Alamo Junction Rail Park are expanding their rail ability to offer a wells of Eagle Ford south of San Antonio. And in Port Arthur, Global Partners recently announced skeleton to build a 200-acre rail depot means of receiving dual oil trains a day and storing 340,000 barrels of crude.
Rail attention executives contend they can contend reserve as they raise to lift some-more oil.
“In light of these increasing volumes, railroads have taken countless stairs to raise wanton oil safety,” a American Association of Railroads pronounced in a news final month, “from a preference of routes, to sight speeds, to lane and apparatus inspections.”
In new months, sovereign officials have been expanding their concentration from a volume of wanton oil to a composition. Oil from a Bakken, a dialect pronounced in a report, has “a aloft gas content, aloft fog pressure, reduce peep indicate and hot indicate and so a aloft grade of sensitivity than many other crudes in a U.S., that correlates to increasing ignitability and flammability.”
Now, according to Gordon Delcambre, a orator for a sovereign Pipeline and Hazardous Materials Safety Administration in Washington, inspectors are creation unannounced visits to oil producers in Texas. So far, they have collected samples from “half a dozen” hoses pumping wanton from a Eagle Ford Shale arrangement into rail tank cars. He described a contrast as “due attention as distant as reserve is endangered to make certain we know a combination of a element entrance out of a ground.”
To a certain extent, it is not formidable to establish a properties of a collection of oil. Using a sincerely elementary margin test, producers customarily magnitude a firmness on a scale famous as a API Gravity. Higher numbers meant lighter oils, reduction diluted and some-more profitable during a refinery money register. In Texas, producers news a formula to a state Railroad Commission.
But while wanton oil is, by definition, a dangerous material, last properties like explosiveness requires some-more endless combination contrast in a laboratory. Producers have tiny proclivity to commence that analysis, nonetheless some do take dear stairs to stabilise their wanton by stealing components like methane and butane.
“How flighty is volatile?” pronounced Paul Bommer, a petroleum engineering consultant during a University of Texas during Austin. “That’s a tough doubt to answer. You’d have to take your bucket of oil to a lab and do some arrange of flammability test.”
In an emergency, some experts say, a start of a wanton competence spin out to matter little.
“At a finish of a day, we have incendiary liquids that bake in rail cars, about 22,000 gallons of it per rail car, about 8 times what’s in a tractor-trailer,” pronounced Sam Goldwater, a glow and rail reserve consultant formed in San Antonio. “If your expectancy is that my glow dialect should be means to put out a tractor-trailer glow during a Shell station, how do we feel about something 8 times bigger?”
Across a country, glow officials have requested puncture supports to ready for a derailment. The U.S. Senate Appropriations Committee has authorized a check that would persevere $2 million to specialized training, and a rail attention has paid to fly firefighters in for three-day seminars during a trickery in Pueblo, Colorado. On Aug. 22, a Federal Railroad Administration announced $350,000 in grants to financial reserve efforts for brief line railroads. In Harris County, pronounced Asst. Chief Royall, “there’s no doubt a antennas are adult and tuned in to a fact that it could occur here, nonetheless it’s only one of many hurdles we face.”
The U.S. Department of Transportation has due new regulations on rail workman training, oil combination testing, sight speed and tank automobile construction. Responding to a proposal, Edward R. Hamberger, boss of a American Association of Railroads, betrothed cooperation, embracing his industry’s purpose “in a country’s swell toward appetite independence, relocating some-more appetite products like wanton oil and ethanol than ever before.”
Out in a far-flung oil towns of Texas, as they watch their load lift divided from a sight station, drillers can design their shipments will customarily strech their end safely. Railroads consistently brief reduction oil than other modes of land transport, and a amounts of spillage declined between a 1990s and some-more new years, according to a news released in May by a Congressional Research Service.
Still, some perspective a tank cars rolling by a state with heedful eyes.
“Most of a rail lines go right by a core of Houston on their approach to a refineries,” pronounced Tom Smith, executive of a Texas bureau of a supervision and attention watchdog organisation Public Citizen. “In all likelihood, this is a disaster watchful to happen.”
© 2014 MRT.com. All rights reserved. This element competence not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.
Monday, Sep 1, 2014 8:38 pm.